Guildmaster Idle

This game has a good concept but and lacks polish. I don’t know if this is a school project, or a solo project. I’m stuck in bed with COVID so I’m playing it for a diversion. I think it has promise. First the good stuff. I like the material collection system. It is like an idle game at first, you have to do all the work. Eventually you can hire undead to work for you. They collect slowly, so if you need something fast you will need to collect it yourself. The quest system is a good idea and it seems to work well. The food and potion creation, where you have to experiment to discover the recipes, is a good touch. The wiki is a big help! The bad stuff. The talent tree is unbalanced and needs tuned. Some of the talents are over powered. You can train multiple talents at the same time. You can watch an add to skip all the time locks on the talent tree. I have already completed almost all the talent trees and I’m not that far into the game. Another thing, some of the gear enhancements don’t have any material requirements. You can train high end gear straight to level 99 as soon as you get it. Also, I would like to see how the gear affects each class. I find myself guessing what might be the best gear for each. I have high hopes for this game. As I said it has potential. I hope it is still a work in process and it will be finished one day.

I thoroughly enjoy this game. I would recommend it. I’ve read some of the reviews and a wiki would be helpful. Also some UI improvements just to make things accessible. But I do like the map layout, I’ve put some time into this game. I’ve yet to “complete” the first dungeon. I’ve got that to look forward to. But what would be really neato is if a fella could have a battle with the adventurers you have. Like a neat little boss battle or interactive dungeon where it’s like Fallout Shelter. Send out your guys, and in like 3 or 4 hours they’ve arrived. Fight a hand full of goblins and then only have like 1 or 2 hours for them to return to the city. And customizable characters. Idk some characters I have just look silly. But I suppose the random characters make for incentive to reroll just for an aesthetic. Overall really 5 stars. I really hope the devs can stick with this and continue to build on it while not getting too deep into the tropes that idle games have.

I love this game. You don’t feel rushed to complete 20 things in order to get daily rewards. Also, you slowly build your own team and start raising dungeons. It’s a simple game and the mini games themselves are fun for kids. I love the fact that, after putting some time in harvesting resources and researching most of the stuff in the game now I can focus more on rating, dungeons and training up my adventures. I don’t have to spend two hours a day in order to make decent progress after all my upgrades, I can play 10 minutes here in 10 minutes there and still I’m engaged. Give the game a chance if you like idle RPGs. I am looking forward to more updates